Why I Stopped Using Fitness Trackers
I make no claim of being, or ever having been, a particularly fit person. I’ve never had a gym membership nor do I exercise daily. But I enjoy walking, biking, swimming, and dancing, and try to use a combination of those to stay in shape. And as a person who has owned smartwatches, I’ve also fallen prey to the fitness tracker.
When I had an iPhone I had an Apple Watch. When I switched to a Pixel I got a Pixel Watch. I subscribed to Gentler Streak over on iOS for a while. I’ve had Strava installed. I’ve tried to deal with whichever app Google is pushing at the time. I tracked step steaks, monitored my readiness scores, logged my bike rides.
I guess I figured that if I was already going to be walking/biking/swimming, I might as well log the workout? The watches made it friction-less to the point where they’d try to guess what I was doing even if I didn’t let them know. So log them I did. I never felt like it added anything to my workouts or my life, but… it’s what everyone was doing?
In my life overall I’ve been thinking a lot about what it means to live intentionally, which naturally leads one to want to spend less time staring at devices. Every time I filled a spot of free time with my phone or my computer, I would think to myself - what would I be doing right now if it were 1996?
My mental journey into “life like it’s the ’90s” should and probably will be the subject of its own post. But one thing I kept thinking to myself was that people in 1996 didn’t need their Fitbit to congratulate them on their workout or tell them they crushed it on that bike ride today. They didn’t need a readiness score or HRV number to tell them what kind of workout they should do today. And it isn’t as though our having these things has made us tremendously healthier than people of generations past.
I made the mistake of falling asleep with my Pixel Watch on one night very shortly after my son was born. Google’s newly mandatory AI chat bot built into the Health app was appropriately negative in the morning, letting me know that I had slept very poorly and how I really ought to prioritize rest today. Sure, Google. Do you want to come feed my newborn at midnight, 03:00, and 06:00 for me?
The final straw was a couple weeks ago as I wallowed in a hospital bed with an NG tube down my nose and throat after a fluke abdominal issue. I was on a nothing-by-mouth diet daydreaming about water. It hurt to swallow, it hurt to talk, I was basically tethered to a bed, and it was nearly impossible to turn my head to the left. I had recently started biking again, which had awakened the Strava app I forgot I still had from its notification slumber. My phone went ping, and it was Strava telling me to get out there! Seize the day! Keep your streak alive!
This was the straw that broke the camel’s back. These apps and trackers are not, as far as I’m concerned, really interested in keeping us healthy. They are just looking for engagement. And I get it, that streak might be incredibly helpful and motivational to some people! It just isn’t for me. It’s not motivational, and having an app tell me to go for a bike ride when I was desperately sad and trapped in a hospital bed was just adding insult to injury.
It’s OK to go for a walk or a ride and not know exactly how many miles you went. It’s OK to go for a swim and not know how many laps you swam or what your average heart rate was. If you like this data - great! I do understand that for serious athletes this information might be indispensable. But for me? it was freeing to just opt out entirely.
Workouts still count even if the only thing that knows they happened is you.